Thou Shalt Not Get Hacked: Prioritizing Cybersecurity Awareness and Tips for Protecting Modern Churches

In today’s digital world, churches are relying more heavily on technology to manage their operations, communicate with congregants, and fulfill their mission. While these tools offer incredible opportunities to reach and serve people, they also come with significant risks—risks that many church leaders may not fully recognize until it’s too late.

As an executive pastor or church leader, your primary focus is on shepherding your congregation, spreading the Gospel, and providing ministry support. However, ignoring the importance of cybersecurity can jeopardize these very goals. A ransomware attack or data breach could not only disrupt church operations but also compromise the trust your members place in your leadership.

Today, we will explore why cybersecurity awareness is crucial for churches, reflect on a hypothetical (yet all too realistic) situation in which a church fell victim to a cyberattack, and offer practical advice to help protect your ministry from similar threats.

Key Takeaways

• Churches Are Increasingly Vulnerable to Cyberattacks: With limited budgets, reliance on volunteers or minimal IT staff, and valuable data stored in their systems, churches are prime targets for cybercriminals. Since 2020, there has been a noticeable increase in attacks against churches, highlighting the importance of cybersecurity awareness.

• Cyberattacks Have Far-Reaching Consequences: A data breach or ransomware attack can disrupt ministry operations, erode trust within the congregation, and lead to significant financial and emotional strain. Proactively addressing cybersecurity risks helps safeguard both the church’s mission and the trust of its members.

• Cybersecurity Awareness is Key to Prevention: By educating staff and volunteers, implementing strong policies, and fostering a culture of responsibility, churches can reduce their risk of falling victim to attacks. Regular training, phishing simulations, and reliable data backups are practical steps that can help protect a ministry in the digital age.

  
  

---

A Wake-Up Call: A Church Falls Victim to Ransomware

Imagine this: your church serves 2,500 congregants every Sunday, employs 40 ministry staff members, engages 20 regular volunteers and relies on technology to manage nearly every aspect of its operations. One day, a staff member receives an email that appears to be from the senior pastor. The subject line reads: “URGENT: Review This Document Before Sunday’s Service.” Without a second thought, the staff member clicks on the link, unknowingly allowing ransomware to infiltrate the church’s network.

Within hours, critical systems are locked, sensitive data is encrypted, and a ransom demand appears on the screen. Online giving platforms, email systems, and member databases are rendered inaccessible. Panic sets in as staff scramble to assess the damage, and church leaders are left with difficult questions:

• How did this happen?

• Could it have been prevented?

• How do we recover and rebuild trust with our congregation?

  
  

For many church leaders, this scenario feels like a nightmare—but it’s a reality that has affected countless organizations, including churches, in recent years. Cybercriminals often target non-profits and religious organizations, assuming they have limited resources and weak cybersecurity defenses.

---

Why Churches Are Vulnerable to Cyberattacks

Churches may not seem like obvious targets for cybercriminals, but they are often more vulnerable than other organizations for several reasons:

1. Limited IT Resources

   Many churches operate on tight budgets, allocating most of their resources to ministry work. As a result, IT infrastructure and cybersecurity measures may be outdated or insufficient. Additionally, it is not uncommon for churches to have only one IT support person or to depend on volunteers who have some technical knowledge.

   
   

2. Lack of Cybersecurity Awareness

   Staff and volunteers may not be trained to recognize phishing emails, weak passwords, or other common security risks. This lack of awareness can make it easier for attackers to exploit human error.

   
   

3. Valuable Data

   Churches collect and store sensitive information, including member contact info, giving records, prayers requests, and even private counseling details. This data can be highly valuable to cybercriminals who sell it on the black market or use it for further attacks.

   
   

4. Perceived Trustworthiness

   Cybercriminals know that churches rely on trust and open communication. An email appearing to come from a trusted pastor or leader can easily trick well-meaning staff or volunteers.

   
   

5. Overlooked Security Needs

   Many churches assume they are too small or insignificant to be targeted, leading to a false sense of security. This mindset can result in inadequate protection measures and an unprepared response to attacks.

   
   

While statistics are still being gathered about cyberattacks on churches, it remains that there has been an increase in attacks against churches since around 2020. This trend highlights the growing need for vigilance and proactive measures to protect ministry operations.

The Impact of a Cyberattack on Ministry

The consequences of a cyberattack on a church go far beyond financial losses. Operational disruptions can bring ministry activities to a halt, as key systems such as membership databases, email platforms, and online giving portals become inaccessible. This can force the cancellation of events or suspension of services, directly impacting the congregation and community. Moreover, churches are built on trust, and a data breach that exposes member information or disrupts giving platforms can erode that trust, leaving members questioning the church’s ability to safeguard their resources and personal data. Financial strain is another significant consequence, as recovering from an attack often requires extensive IT services, new technology investments, or even ransom payments (though these are never recommended). For churches with tight budgets, such costs can detract from vital ministry programs. Finally, the emotional toll on staff and leaders cannot be overlooked. The stress and anxiety caused by a cyberattack can diminish morale and confidence, leaving church leaders feeling guilt or shame even when the attack was beyond their control.

The Role of Cybersecurity Awareness

While the risks are real, the good news is that churches can take meaningful steps to protect themselves. Cybersecurity awareness is one of the most effective ways to prevent attacks and minimize their impact. Here’s why it matters and how to implement it in your church.

Most cyberattacks, including phishing scams and ransomware, rely on human error. By educating staff and volunteers about common threats and how to recognize them, you can significantly reduce your church’s vulnerability. For example, staff should be taught to verify unexpected emails or requests for sensitive information, even if they appear to come from a trusted source. You can watch this brief video for quick tips on how to spot a phishing email. Encouraging caution when clicking on links or downloading attachments from unknown senders is also crucial. Additionally, emphasizing the importance of using strong, unique passwords or passsphrases and enabling two-factor authentication can provide an extra layer of security.

Cybersecurity awareness also helps your team understand the importance of safeguarding sensitive information. Churches collect and store a great deal of personal and financial data, making it essential to treat member data as a sacred trust. By doing so, your church can reinforce its commitment to protecting the privacy and security of its congregation.

Finally, fostering a culture of responsibility ensures that cybersecurity becomes a shared effort across the entire church. Everyone, from senior pastors to volunteers, plays a role in protecting the church from cyber threats. This proactive mindset helps create a culture of vigilance and accountability, ensuring that your ministry can continue to thrive in the digital age.

Practical Steps to Improve Cybersecurity Awareness for Churches

1. Conduct Regular Training

   Host training sessions for staff and volunteers on identifying phishing emails, using secure passwords, and following best practices for online safety. Make training accessible and engaging, and repeat it regularly to keep everyone informed about evolving threats.

2. Implement a Clear Cybersecurity Policy

   Establish guidelines for handling sensitive information, using church devices, and responding to suspicious activity. Ensure everyone understands and follows these policies.

3. Simulate Phishing Scams

   Test your team’s awareness by sending simulated phishing emails. This can help identify vulnerabilities and provide opportunities for learning in a safe environment.

4. Invest in Cybersecurity Tools

   Use tools like antivirus software, firewalls, and email filtering to block threats before they reach your staff. Partnering with an IT professional or managed service provider, like Keyn Solutions, can help you implement these solutions effectively.

5. Backup Critical Data

   Ensure your church has a reliable data backup system in place. Regularly test backups to confirm they can be restored in the event of a ransomware attack or system failure.

6. Develop an Incident Response Plan

   Prepare for the worst by creating a plan that outlines how your church will respond to a cyberattack. Include steps for isolating affected systems, notifying stakeholders, and working with IT professionals to recover.

Balancing Ministry and Security

As church leaders, it’s natural to prioritize ministry over technology. After all, your calling is to serve people, not manage IT systems. However, ignoring cybersecurity risks can hinder your ability to fulfill that calling. Protecting your church’s digital assets is not a distraction from ministry—it’s an essential part of it.

By taking proactive steps to improve cybersecurity awareness, you can ensure that your church remains a safe and trusted place for your congregation to grow in faith. More importantly, you’ll be stewarding the resources and relationships God has entrusted to you, honoring His call to lead with wisdom and integrity.

Moving Forward with Confidence

If your church has experienced a cyberattack—or if the possibility keeps you up at night—you’re not alone. Many organizations, including churches, have faced these challenges and emerged stronger by learning from their experiences.

Let this be a wake-up call to take action, not out of fear, but out of faith in the God who equips us for every good work. With prayerful planning and practical steps, you can protect your church from cyber threats and continue your ministry with confidence and peace of mind.

Would you like assistance implementing a cybersecurity plan or training for your church? Keyn Solutions is here to help! Reach out today at (909-347-0345) or email us at info@keynsolutions.com to get started. You don’t need to tackle everything all at once—the important thing is to take that first step. Begin with your free Cybersecurity Kickstarter Kit, designed to help your ministry build a strong foundation for digital security. Let’s work together to protect your church and ensure it remains a safe, trusted place for years to come.